

History at its' best
Very informative! Just how did Grant take Vicksburg?
A signpost to even greater richesWhile the Vicksburg campaign, being (in my simple opinion, anyway) more of coup de grace than a turning point, lacks the supreme drama of the battle at Gettysburg (magnificently presented in Foote's "The Stars In Their Courses", over which I have raved elsewhere), it is an amazing story in its own right. As always, not only does Foote brilliantly limn the military action with stirring prose of an almost Homeric grandeur, he unearths the small human details that bring the long-ago events to life with shuddering poignancy. (i.e. A Union commander preparing to assault a Confederate fort at daybreak reports that from behind the enemy's walls he heard "the prettiest reveille I ever did hear", or General McClernand maintaining his military reserve even as a distraught Southern woman defiantly sings "The Bonnie Blue Flag" right in his face.) He is fortunate, of course, to be studying a period in which even humble footsoldiers, steeped in the cadences of the King James Bible, commanded a musical quality of rhetoric that puts today's orators to shame. (i.e. A disgruntled newspaper editor begs his political friend to convince Lincoln that General Grant is "a jackass in the original package", and a captured Union officer gallantly inquires of his captors, "Is this the Army of the Confederacy for which I have so long and earnestly sought? Then, sirs, I am your guest for the duration.")
A very special treat is the audio edition, read by Foote himself in a smoky Mississippi drawl that could not be better suited to the text. It's akin to hearing the great national epic patiently recited by the Voice of America itself.


Anton's Chehov early short stories is a must have book
Take one a day as a preventative of stupidityHighest possible recommendation!
...lesson one..

More Than a Dynasty
Combination biography and investment ideasThe book traces the investment history of Shelby Davis to his son to his grandsons. Shelby had family money through his wife and starts investing shortly after the crash in '29. Like many people, I assumed the market has been a somewhat continual climb with some setbacks. This books traces the history showing the many periods of lackluster stock value growth and how most Americans shunned the stock market for bonds. Quite a difference from today.
The original Shelby was a miserly value investor who never spent an extra dime. His investment hits were insurance stocks when no one liked that industry and some prudent investments in Japan, also mainly in the insurance industry. By leaving these investments to compound for years, Shelby built a great fortune. But the hidden engine behind this vast growth was the use of margin to leverage his returns. The original Shelby eventually grew his fortune to over a billion dollars in value.
Shelby's son Shelby did not work with his father until late in his life but eventually became a money manager of some renown also. His philosophy was similar but different and his large money winners tended to be from other industries. The book ends with the sons of Shelby Jr. taking over their father's money management firm and establishing their own identity.
Along this 70 year history, you will learn about the markets and the different stages of development over the years. A significant amount of time is spent in the 60s and 70s as both of the Shelby's were investing at that time. I strongly recommend this book if you have interest in the market and its history.
Highly Recommended!

Excellent overview of Special Forces in Southeast Asia
Most comprehensive record of SF operations in SE Asia
Excellent summary of Special Forces operations in SE Asia

Helped Curb a Belligerent (Not Terribly Benign) Tumor!
Not Only a Well-Written Hypothesis Lacking Impact, But...
Helpful review of adolescent faith development.

Destiny!!
Family SecretsHannibal had his own ghosts to slay. He never really had anything of material value and didn't care. He started thinking about that those things when he started to get to know Josephine. Aunt Cordelia was a trip. When I started reading this book, I said to myself "This woman has a real problem." I was right and in the book it reveals all of Cordelia's past. Destiny, which is the name of a town in Oklahoma was full of secrets and the people who kept them.
This is my first romance written by Shelby Lewis. I thought the book could have been a little longer, but was really good.
Josephine and Hannibal - Destined For One Another!

Thumping Good Rea
A Thrilling Plot to Assassinate the American President
First Rate Book!!

Washington's senator
In it's fourth prininting. If you haven't read this book, D
a well done precise history of a powerful man.

A rare miss for Shelby FootePerhaps unfairly, novels of the Civil War tend to get compared to Michael Shaara's brilliant Killer Angels, a comparison that does not bode well for Shiloh. Here Foote tries to tell the story of the battle by providing first person narratives by a number of foot soldiers and adjutants, who often spend most of the battle lost, since I think Foote was trying to portray the confusion of this first great battle of the Civil War, with about 100,000 soldiers on the field and almost 25% casualties. However his narrative style ends up creating a jumbled mess, with no interaction between the characters, and not enough personal insight to make the reader remember or care about any of the narrators.
It seemed to me that Foote the historian is effectively telling the history of the battle and providing biographical info of certain major players, like Albert Sidney Johnston, Ulysses Grant and Nathan Bedford Forrest, and he occasionally throws in a forced reference to a girlfriend back home or a memory from school to remind the reader this is a novel. In particular the very beginning, where assistants tell the reader all about the history of Generals Johnston and Grant (under whom they supposedly serve), seemed contrived. If you enjoyed the campfire banter of Lee and Longstreet in Killer Angels, or the heroic determination of Lewis Armistead to do his duty without harming his good friend Winfield Hancock, you will find nothing comparable here.
I should point out that the audio version of this book had an excellent afterword by the author, where Foote puts the battle in context, discusses his views on literature and especially literature about war, and recounts a trip to Shiloh battlefield he made with William Faulkner in 1952 around the 90th anniversary of the battle. Here is Foote at his finest, spinning a yarn and discussing topics including "Grant was drunk" - (which he denies) and "Grant was surprised" (Foote thinks surely he was, which is a testament to his genius as a general). The excellent afterword, which I enjoyed a lot more than novel, elevated this audio set to 3 1/2 stars in my opinion.
fine Civil War novel, but flawedFoote is one of the great authorities on the War, and though he wrote this when pretty young it is still filled with detail and knowledge of the war. It conveys well the chaos of the fighting and how, as so often, small failures of generalship cost the battle.
However, I found the plotting pretty contrived, and the effort to tell the battle through multiple viewpoints was not really helped by the way the different characters kept unwittingly crossing each other. Also, though this book was certainly ahead of its time in trying to convey the war through ordinary men's eyes, you sensed that Foote was actually more drawn to the leaders who he used the soldiers to describe - Forrest, Grant, Sherman etc. Also, the method he uses, and the whole way in which Shiloh was neither defeat or victory for either side, means the ending is curiously unsatisfying and unresolved - unlike the war itself.
But, if there's something that doesn't quite work about this book, there's a lot that does. Enjoy.
A battle from each sideFoote tells the story of 6 different participants in the battle, both Union and Confederate. The men are tired, scared, brave, leaders, and runners. The book is short, only 226 pages, but we feel their fear and excitment, even if only for a moment, along with their short-sighted view of the fighting. Here there is no grand view of the entire battle nor of the tactics and planning. These are largely the fighters who carry out the orders, not knowing why most of the time, only that they are soldiers and this is what they do.
Originally published well before the Shaara trilogy, Shiloh ranks with them and The Red Badge of Courage in the emotion and story telling. The reader becomes part of the action for a short while, until you can almost smell the gunpowder.


Too much Foote, Not enough Percy!
interesting but unsettlingIt's a bit sickening to watch on as Foote seduces the wife of a local doctor, and later recommends to Percy (oh so wittily) that he use pillows to prop up the crotches of female UNC undergrads so that they might better serve his wishes.
On the bright side, it is hilarious to watch Foote react to a letter from a clueless librarian accusing him of failing to mention Gettysburg in his history (she seems not to have realized that it was a multi-volume work). Even more importantly, the entire collection is thought-provoking.
Pity poor Shelby FooteThe reader of this book of letters between two friends will be thrilled by talk of literature. Foote is like Herr Settembrini of Thomas Mann's "The Magic Mountain". He is so overwhelmed by humantistic learning that he finds he must educate his friend and mentor Hans Castrop, in this case Walker Percy.
It is ironic that the prodigy in this case, Walker Percy, soon eclipses the mentor. Walker Percy agonizes in his early letters about his inability to have his novels published while Foote publishes his books in rapid succession. But today Percy's "Moviegoer" and other books are still read while only Foote's "Shiloh" is really still popular. It seems Foote is stuck with Civil War fame have written his long classic on the war.
Reading Foote's letters is where I discovered Flanney O'Connor. Walker Percy and Shelby Foote spoke highly of her here. They also talk about the important of reading Marcel Proust, Faulkner, and a dozen others. Toward the end Foote begins to spew forth on the merits of reading the Greek classics. It is his description of these books and their authors that adds to one's own literary education.
The first part of the book is a little annoying because Shelby Foote threw away the letters that Walker Percy sent to him for the first many years of their correspondence. So you keep reading Shelby Foote but are not privvy to what Walker Percy as to say.